"All this he saw, for one moment breathless and intense, vivid on the morning sky; and still, as he looked, he lived; and still, as he lived, he wondered."

For the Benefit of Mankind

Cixin Liu is one of the most brilliant sci-fi writers of our time and some of his short stories have been adapted into graphic novels.”For the Benefit of Mankind” is a story I found in the collectiontitled after “The Wandering Earrh” and one of the most particular, as the main character is a contract killer and the whole story has a noir feeling to it. A noir with aliens.

It’s one of my favourite stories from the collection, and I was curious to see how they would adapt the layered timelines, the Elder Brothers and their plan, their background, and how the whole concept unfolds through the main character’s meeting with his targets, alongside the whole noir atmosphere.There are differences. Some of them I understand, while others feel like the authors were a bit too preoccupied that people wouldn’t understand, and the nuances of the original story are a bit tuned down.

My least favourite changes are whose idea was the redistribution of wealth, and who’s commissioning the last job. Also, in the original novel the Last Capitalis was a loner who liked to go jogging, while here he’s a guy with a whole golden court and I don’t think I like that.

My favourite change is probably the epilogue, though it clashes with the noir atmosphere.

Anyway, a highly enjoyable adaptation.

books and literature

Ioanna Papadopoulou’s The Castaway and the Witch

I had a genuine “oh shit” moment when I read the author’s preface saying this was darker than “Winter Harvest” because – and I absolutely ADORED “Winter Harvest” – that was pitch-black dark. I thought “we’re all going to die”. This maybe has something to

Read More »
Summertime

The Path You Have to Sing

Alexis Wright‘s Carpentaria, an epic work set in a fictional town called Desperance, opens before there are any people in it at all: an ancestral serpent, “a creature larger than storm clouds,” descends from the stars and drags itself across the wet clay of the

Read More »
movies and tv

But for pursuit of virtue and of knowledge

I’m sure you’ve read enough analysis of Nolan’s Odyssey to last a lifetime, and you don’t need another European ranting that he changed stuff, so I’m not going to. Instead, I’d like to talk about the movie in itself, as an independent work, granting the

Read More »
Share on LinkedIn
Throw on Reddit
Roll on Tumblr
Mail it
No Comments

Post A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

RELATED POSTS

Ioanna Papadopoulou’s The Castaway and the Witch

I had a genuine “oh shit” moment when I read the author’s preface saying this was darker than “Winter Harvest” because – and I absolutely ADORED “Winter Harvest” – that was pitch-black dark. I thought “we’re all going to die”. This maybe has something to

Read More

The Path You Have to Sing

Alexis Wright‘s Carpentaria, an epic work set in a fictional town called Desperance, opens before there are any people in it at all: an ancestral serpent, “a creature larger than storm clouds,” descends from the stars and drags itself across the wet clay of the

Read More

But for pursuit of virtue and of knowledge

I’m sure you’ve read enough analysis of Nolan’s Odyssey to last a lifetime, and you don’t need another European ranting that he changed stuff, so I’m not going to. Instead, I’d like to talk about the movie in itself, as an independent work, granting the

Read More