Marianne Moore was an American modernist poet, critic, editor, and translator known for her wit and formal experimentation. She was born in Missouri in 1887, studied at Bryn Mawr College, and became one of the major voices of 20th-century American poetry.
Selected Poems is one of the books that helped establish Moore’s reputation by gathering poems from her earlier work into a more widely accessible form. It appeared in 1935 and showcases the qualities she is best known for: exact diction, compressed language, syllabic verse, irony, and close attention to animals, objects, and moral perception. If you read it, look for how Moore turns ordinary things into sharp, intellectually layered poetry.
Moore’s poem “Poetry” is very meta, and it opens by admitting she dislikes the stuff.
“I, too, dislike it. Reading it, however, with a perfect contempt for it,
one discovers in it after all, a place for the genuine.”
Then spends the rest of its length arguing, in spite of itself, for exactly what would redeem it. The phrase everyone remembers is “imaginary gardens with real toads in them,” which Moore sets off in quotation marks as if borrowing it from somewhere, though no source has ever been traced; most readers now assume she invented it and then disguised it as a quotation because it felt too neat to own outright. Whatever its origin, it names the standard the whole poem is built around: invention is fine, even necessary, but only if something genuinely real is still living inside it. However ugly that might be.
I don’t think this is really a poem about poetry in general so much as a poem about a specific professional temptation, the one where a compelling overall concept excuses you from including reality. Moore calls the alternative a “literalist of the imagination,” someone who invents freely and still insists, at every point, on being exact about what the invented thing is actually made of and how it actually behaves. That’s a much harder discipline than either pure invention or pure documentation on their own, because it demands both simultaneously: the garden has to be imaginary enough to be worth building, and the toad inside it has to be real enough to survive being touched.
No Comments